One relatively unnoticed consequence of this arrangement is that, against
conventional economic wisdom, the industrialists-and the general public-
came to believe that the sheer stockpiling of advanced weapons was ipso
facto a sign of strength, not weakness. Of course, if one's model of achievement
were a full, albeit unused, library, rather than a cleared warehouse, then
it made good sense. In this respect, endless technoscientific expansion became
both the means and the ends of the Cold War. Moreover, this policy has continued
largely unabated with the fall of the Soviet Union. The only difference
is that the state no longer occupies the role of central planner and coordinator.
Nevertheless, the cross-national metrics of techno scientific achievement
devised in the Cold War remain in place, most notably the Science Citation
Index, only now enhanced by related measures of intellectual property. Yet, as
in the Cold War, there remains an enormous gap between counting articles,
patents, and citations, on the one hand, and measuring the effectiveness of
these quantities vis-a-vis their target realities, on the other ( Fuller 2002a, chap.
l ) . Only the most sociologically naive academic administrator or science
policy manager would presume that there is some straightforward connection
between such counts and measures. Luckily, at least for the employment
prospects of STS researchers, sociological naivete is never in short supply (e.g.,
Etzkowitz et al. 1 998) .
Steve Fullers - 2006 Philophical foundations of sociology of science
lunes, 17 de septiembre de 2018
domingo, 16 de septiembre de 2018
Serres 1992 - Dominar Dominio
Nuestras conquistas van más rápido que nuestras intenciones deliberadas. Miren, en efecto, la aceleración de nuestros avances técnicos. Basta que se anuncie que tal avance es posible, y lo vemos realizado en algún parte del planeta, considerado en seguida como deseable, e incluso necesario… Sí, podremos elegir el sexo de nuestros hijos, sí, la genética, la bioquímica, la nos terminaran dando todos los poderes. Pero ese poder, por el momento, se nos escapa de las manos, ya que va más lejos y más rápido que nuestra capacidad de preveerlo, que nuestra capacidad de gestionarlo, que nuestra voluntad de decidir sobre él, que nuestra libertad para orientarlo. Hemos resuelto la cuestión cartesiana: ¿Cómo someter el mundo, cómo dominar la naturaleza?. Sabremos responder esta otra cuestión: ¿Cómo dominar nuestro dominio? (Serres, 1992, p. 250)
Filosofia Unisinos, 13(2-supplement):266-279, october 2012 - Eduardo Casaroti.
Filosofia Unisinos, 13(2-supplement):266-279, october 2012 - Eduardo Casaroti.
viernes, 31 de agosto de 2018
Reifing nature - Mike Michael
This returns us to
Latour's advocacy of a strategic realism (infrareflexivity).
If what we aim to do
is convince others via our polished representations, and
if part of this
process entails the attempted inoculation of our texts against
the outrages of the
deconstructionists who everywhere lie in wait, one option
is to evoke and invoke the real as
energetically and cannily as possible. This
'real' could be the
typically 'social' (e.g. interests, values, institutional positioning
and the like), or it
could be the typically 'non-social' and 'nonhuman' .
It all depends on
the contexts and exigencies - both social and non-social.
Thus to 'reify' the environmental crisis, animal
suffering or human disease
and despair is perfectly acceptable when one's purpose
is to enable and
encourage
political action and to enrol others as political activists.
Mike Michael , 1997 - PP 39
lunes, 27 de agosto de 2018
Oslak - 1994
Oslak 1994 -
"No existe ni ha existido, por lo tanto, una voluntad expansiva del estado con independencia de la
voluntad de quienes lo han conducido, colonizado o explotado en su beneficio. Y sin embargo, los
que hoy propician retóricamente su encogimiento son los propios sectores que casi siempre fueron
sus principales beneficiarios. En su discurso, los motes "estado empresario" y "estado empleador"
simbolizan la hipertrofia y el gigantismo. "Olvidan" agregar que los estados contratista, comprador y
subsidiador, otras de las caras de este Jano multifronte, fueron tanto o más responsables de esa
expansión. Obviamente, sólo a través de ciertas formas de influencia o control ejercidas por dichos
sectores, pudieron desarrollarse estas otras formas de intervención estatal que acabaron
engrosando sus instituciones y recursos. "
" Puede advertirse que estas críticas de izquierda y derecha destacaban, en realidad, dos fenómenos diferentes: por una parte, el impacto de la organización estatal sobre la estructura de poder de la sociedad moderna; y, por otra, la índole de su función social, es decir, su capacidad y posibilidades de servir a objetivos de interés general (Oszlak, 1976, 1984). Es decir, el temprano cuestionamiento del estado tuvo dos fundamentos dife rentes. El más explícito consistió en declarar -como ocurre actualmente- la incompetencia del estado para la gestión de los asuntos sociales, su menor productividad y eficiencia frente a otras instancias de gestión. El menos visible, el cuestionamiento del poder adquirido por el mismo frente a otros actores sociales. "
Link : http://unpan1.un.org/intradoc/groups/public/documents/un-dpadm/unpan040064.pdf
"No existe ni ha existido, por lo tanto, una voluntad expansiva del estado con independencia de la
voluntad de quienes lo han conducido, colonizado o explotado en su beneficio. Y sin embargo, los
que hoy propician retóricamente su encogimiento son los propios sectores que casi siempre fueron
sus principales beneficiarios. En su discurso, los motes "estado empresario" y "estado empleador"
simbolizan la hipertrofia y el gigantismo. "Olvidan" agregar que los estados contratista, comprador y
subsidiador, otras de las caras de este Jano multifronte, fueron tanto o más responsables de esa
expansión. Obviamente, sólo a través de ciertas formas de influencia o control ejercidas por dichos
sectores, pudieron desarrollarse estas otras formas de intervención estatal que acabaron
engrosando sus instituciones y recursos. "
" Puede advertirse que estas críticas de izquierda y derecha destacaban, en realidad, dos fenómenos diferentes: por una parte, el impacto de la organización estatal sobre la estructura de poder de la sociedad moderna; y, por otra, la índole de su función social, es decir, su capacidad y posibilidades de servir a objetivos de interés general (Oszlak, 1976, 1984). Es decir, el temprano cuestionamiento del estado tuvo dos fundamentos dife rentes. El más explícito consistió en declarar -como ocurre actualmente- la incompetencia del estado para la gestión de los asuntos sociales, su menor productividad y eficiencia frente a otras instancias de gestión. El menos visible, el cuestionamiento del poder adquirido por el mismo frente a otros actores sociales. "
Link : http://unpan1.un.org/intradoc/groups/public/documents/un-dpadm/unpan040064.pdf
miércoles, 1 de agosto de 2018
Bourdieu - Actor Racional
“The ‘rational actor’ theory, which seeks the ‘origin’ of acts, strictly economic or not, in
an ‘intention’ of ‘consciousness’, is
often associated with a narrow conception of the ‘rationality’ of practices, an economism which regards as
rational (or, which amounts to the
same thing in this logic, as economic) those practices that are consciously oriented by the pursuit of
maximum (economic) profit at minimum
(economic) cost. Finalist economism explains practices by relating them directly and exclusively to
economic interests, treated as
consciously posited ends; mechanistic economism relates them no less directly and exclusively to economic
interests, defined just as narrowly
but treated as causes. Both are unaware that practices can have other principles than mechanical
causes or conscious ends and can obey
an economic logic without obeying narrowly economic interests. There is an economy of practices, a reason
immanent in practices, whose ‘origin’ lies
neither in the ‘decisions’ of reason understood as rational calculation nor in the
determinations of mechanisms external to
and superior to the agents. Being constitutive of the structure of rational practice, that is, the practice
most appropriate to achieve the
objectives inscribed in the logic of a particular field at the lowest cost, this economy can be defined in
relation to all kinds of functions,
one of which, among others, is the maximization of monetary profit, the only one recognized by economism.
In other words, if one fails to
recognize any form of action other than rational action or mechanical reaction, it is impossible to
understand the logic of all the
actions that are reasonable without being the product of a reasoned design, still less of rational
calculation; informed by a kind of
objective finality without being consciously organized in relation to an explicitly constituted end;
intelligible and coherent without
springing from an intention of coherence and a deliberate decision; adjusted to the future without
being the product of a project or a
plan. And, if one fails to see that the economy described by economic theory is a particular case of
a whole universe of economies, that
is, of fields of struggle differing both in the stakes and scarcities that are generated within
them and in the forms of capital
deployed in them, it is impossible to account for the specific forms, contents and leverage points thus
imposed on the pursuit of maximum
specific profits and on the very general optimizing strategies (of which economic strategies in the narrow
sense are one form among others). (p.
50-51)
Economism is a form of
ethnocentrism. Treating pre-capitalist
economies, in Marx’s phrase, ‘as the Fathers of the Church treated the religions which preceded Christianity’, it
applies to them categories, methods
(economic accountancy, for example) or concepts (such as the notions of interest, investment or capital)
which are the historical product of
capitalism and which induce a radical transformation of their object, similar to the historical
transformation from which they arose.
Economism recognizes no other form of interest than that which capitalism has produced, through a kind of
real operation of abstraction, by
setting up a universe of relations between man and man based, as Marx says, on ‘callous cash
payment’ and more generally by favouring
the creation of relatively autonomous fields, capable of establishing their own axiomatics (through
the fundamental tautology ‘business is
business’, on which ‘the economy’ is based). It can therefore find no place in its analyses,
still less in its calculations, for
any form of ‘non-economic’ interest. It is as if economic calculation had been able to
appropriate the territory objectively
assigned to the remorseless logic of what Marx calls ‘naked self-interest’, only by
relinquishing an island of the ‘sacred’,
miraculously spared by the ‘icy waters of egoistic calculation’, the refuge of what has no
price because it has too much or too
little. But, above all, it can make nothing of universes that have not performed such a dissociation and
so have, as it were, an economy in
itself and not for itself. Thus, any partial or total objectification of the archaic economy that
does not include a theory of the
subjective relation of misrecognition which agents adapted to this economy maintain with its ‘objective’
(that is, objectivist) truth, succumbs
to the most subtle and most irreproachable form of ethnocentrism. […] By reducing this economy to its ‘objective’
reality, economism annihilates the
specificity located precisely in the socially
maintained discrepancy between the ‘objective’ reality and the social representation of production and exchange.
It is no accident that the vocabulary of
the archaic economy is entirely made up of double-sided notions that are condemned to disintegrate
in the very history of the economy,
because, owing to their duality, the social relations that they designate represent unstable
structures which inevitably split in two
as soon as the social mechanisms sustaining them are weakened.” (p. 112-3)"
Source: https://economicsociology.org/2017/07/19/pierre-bourdieu-economism-is-a-form-of-ethnocentrism/
"Bourdieu evoca um continuum de atividades muito diversas, no qual a atividade de produção simbólica do produto ocupa um lugar mais ou menos importante, tendo cada um sua especificidade. A alta costura, por exemplo, caracteriza-se pela necessidade de inovação permanente. A produção automobilística notabiliza-se entre outras pela preocupação com o design , a criação de marcas e de modelos. Enquanto os autores da economia neoclássica, e mesmo sociólogos que limitam sua atenção à especificidade da economia de certos bens "diferentes de outros", qualificam de "standards " os bens de uso quotidiano, Bourdieu faz referência aos produtos que possuem uma carga simbólica mais ou menos importante: como em A distinção (1979), o sentido atribuído aos produtos ou às práticas não pode ser pensado de modo essencialista, porém relativo. O caráter "standard" ou "simbólico" dos bens não pode ser visto como uma propriedade intrínseca. A distinção entre bens "standard" e bens simbólicos é uma disputa e um instrumento de lutas no espaço em que as trocas econômicas ocorrem. Nada é mais classificador em relação ao indivíduo que seu endereço, a aparência de sua casa, seu modo de se vestir, de comer ou, ainda, a marca de seu carro. Esses são os gostos associados ao quotidiano, que os economistas nomeiam de "preferências reveladas", explicam o sentido da boutade segundo a qual "os classificadores são classificados por sua classificação" (Bourdieu, 1979)."
Marie-France Garcia-Parpet (2013)
http://www.scielo.br/pdf/sant/v3n5/2238-3875-sant-03-05-0091.pdf
http://www.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S2238-38752013000500091
Zukerfeld 2017 - Premio ESOCITE 2018
"Now, at first glance it could seem strange that we consider individual or collective subjects (although actually it is the knowledge that they carry) as an output of some productive processes. Resistance to this idea could have at least two root causes: on the one hand, humanist ontological inertia. On the other hand, a vague idea that productive processes result in ‘goods and services’ and not subjects. In terms of the first, in effect the dominant ontology, especially since industrial capitalism, accustoms us to making a rigid division between objects and subjects: it is a tacit but firmly held belief that objects are produced, but subjects are not. Of course, denaturalising and rejecting this perspective is not at all novel. There are recent and fashionable antecedents in Foucault ([1966] 2002), but above all in Haraway (1991, 1992), Fuller (2009), Sloterdijk (2016) and many more. Unfortunately, these authors do not usually recognise that it is Hegel who, in Phenomenology of Spirit, shows with clarity that subjects produce themselves at the same time as they produce the world. Our concept of productive processes aims to take this Hegelian element and combine it with more contemporary ideas and, above all, to bring it to bear on the historical, empirical, and even economic terrain (although in a different sense to Marx)."
"On the other hand, we are accustomed to associating the result of productive processes with goods and/or certain services. Let us explore this a little. Goods, that is, entities that survive the moment of their production and over which property rights can be exercised, are varied. For example, tables, paper airplanes, software, or texts. Even though the last two are of a particular type (informational goods), it is not difficult to understand that all these examples emerge from something that it is appropriate to call productive processes, which are not necessarily commodity production processes but could be the fruits of leisure time or production for personal consumption."
Zukerfeld 2017 - PP 106 - "Knowledge Flows: From Translation to Capitalism"
"On the other hand, we are accustomed to associating the result of productive processes with goods and/or certain services. Let us explore this a little. Goods, that is, entities that survive the moment of their production and over which property rights can be exercised, are varied. For example, tables, paper airplanes, software, or texts. Even though the last two are of a particular type (informational goods), it is not difficult to understand that all these examples emerge from something that it is appropriate to call productive processes, which are not necessarily commodity production processes but could be the fruits of leisure time or production for personal consumption."
Zukerfeld 2017 - PP 106 - "Knowledge Flows: From Translation to Capitalism"
Steve Fuller (2006) - Introduction
"At the moment, STS suffers from a complacency that results from thinking
that because things can always be otherwise, we never need to commit to anything.
This inference works only if one is a disappointed foundationalist, not
someone who takes seriously that the future is largely what we collectively
I make of it. In this respect, STS as normally practiced is much less of a threat to
the future of science than scientists think. Indeed, we shall see in what follows
that the Science Wars have been so far largely a comedy of errors. Nevertheless,
there is something quite serious at stake-and worth arguing about-that
these pages endeavor to reveal."
"Seen from the inside, all sustainable social practices are rational.
Thus, when practices seem irrational to an outsider, such as the sociologist,
that is probably because she is applying a framework alien to the insiders. This
move has significant implications for the historical study of science"
"By the time we reach this point, it is fair to ask whether STS's failure to recognize
the "epistemic" character of science removes it from the sociology of
knowledge. However we answer this question, the phenomenon is itself worthy
of study as an episode in the sociology of knowledge. The techno scientific turn
may be radical from the standpoint of the intellectual history of STS, but it
also provides an explication, perhaps even legitimation, for associated social
tendencies that have accompanied the decline of the welfare state and the rise
of neo-liberalism. These are associated with the claims that we live in "knowledge
societies" ( Stehr 1 994) in need of "knowledge management" ( Fuller
2002a)."
Steve Fuller (2006)
that because things can always be otherwise, we never need to commit to anything.
This inference works only if one is a disappointed foundationalist, not
someone who takes seriously that the future is largely what we collectively
I make of it. In this respect, STS as normally practiced is much less of a threat to
the future of science than scientists think. Indeed, we shall see in what follows
that the Science Wars have been so far largely a comedy of errors. Nevertheless,
there is something quite serious at stake-and worth arguing about-that
these pages endeavor to reveal."
"Seen from the inside, all sustainable social practices are rational.
Thus, when practices seem irrational to an outsider, such as the sociologist,
that is probably because she is applying a framework alien to the insiders. This
move has significant implications for the historical study of science"
"By the time we reach this point, it is fair to ask whether STS's failure to recognize
the "epistemic" character of science removes it from the sociology of
knowledge. However we answer this question, the phenomenon is itself worthy
of study as an episode in the sociology of knowledge. The techno scientific turn
may be radical from the standpoint of the intellectual history of STS, but it
also provides an explication, perhaps even legitimation, for associated social
tendencies that have accompanied the decline of the welfare state and the rise
of neo-liberalism. These are associated with the claims that we live in "knowledge
societies" ( Stehr 1 994) in need of "knowledge management" ( Fuller
2002a)."
Steve Fuller (2006)
Suscribirse a:
Entradas (Atom)
Sociotécnico
Sociotécnica -> Adjetivo RAE: No existe la palabra sociotécnico en español sino “socio-“ Del lat. socius 'socio', 'comp...
-
"Now, at first glance it could seem strange that we consider individual or collective subjects (although actually it is the knowledge t...
-
One relatively unnoticed consequence of this arrangement is that, against conventional economic wisdom, the industrialists-and the general p...
-
The key tenets were to promote otherwise isolated scientific spokespersons (recruited from gold-plated universities, if possible) who would ...