"Yet, in Science of all places,
there is evidence to the contrary:
Using a database of 34 million articles, their citations (1945 to 2005), and
online availability (1998 to 2005) … as more journal issues came online,
the articles referenced tended to be more recent, fewer journals and
articles were cited, and more of those citations were to fewer journals and
articles … the number of years of commercial availability [of a journal
online] appears to significantly increase concentration of citations to
fewer articles within a journal … These changes likely mean that the shift
from browsing in print to searching online facilitates avoidance of older
and less relevant literature … If online researchers can more easily find
prevailing opinion, they are more likely to follow it, leading to more
citations referencing fewer articles. (Evans 2008, 395, 398)"
"This is just Definition I (vacuum theory) and is a perfectly healthy
phenomenon, a prophylactic for the besetting sin of hubris so common among
intellectuals. Likewise, the exponential growth of scientific publication
renders it impossible to aspire to the status of true polymath and stay on top of
everything. This is Definition 2 (bounded rationality) and is just one
important aspect of our cognitive predicament, that attention and memory are
limited. Of course, we are impelled to develop rules of thumb (and computer
prosthetics) in order to navigate our way through a world far richer than our
paltry abilities to grasp it. Who would argue otherwise? Yet, beyond those
two phenomena, when whole sets of institutions are deliberately bent to sow
doubt, to spew out a fog of contrarian results, to reassure the uneducated that
the truth is whatever they want it to be,7 to treat the unequal distribution of
knowledge as the natural dictate of freedom of choice and simultaneously to
praise the innate “wisdom of crowds,” then a surfeit of ignorance is the
inevitable intentional consequence. This is Definition 3, the manufacture of
ignorance."
Science Mart 2011 - Mirowski
Suscribirse a:
Comentarios de la entrada (Atom)
Sociotécnico
Sociotécnica -> Adjetivo RAE: No existe la palabra sociotécnico en español sino “socio-“ Del lat. socius 'socio', 'comp...
-
This returns us to Latour's advocacy of a strategic realism (infrareflexivity). If what we aim to do is convince others via our...
-
“The ‘rational actor’ theory, which seeks the ‘origin’ of acts, strictly economic or not, in an ‘intention’ of ‘consciousness’, is...
-
One relatively unnoticed consequence of this arrangement is that, against conventional economic wisdom, the industrialists-and the general p...
No hay comentarios.:
Publicar un comentario